We're discussing this burning question over at io9's Facebook page. Right now, Star Wars is winning. Go over there and make your voice heard!
Why is it even necessary? Star Wars' few compelling elements are completely done by the end of Return of the Jedi and any and all 'good bits' after the fact have been systematically disowned.
Roddenberry is dead and much of his vision died with him, and pretty much every attempt to reclaim felt kind of hollow and 'off'. DS9 might get a pass, but it took a long time for that one to get ramped up.
If the Star Wars prequels taught us anything, it's that sometimes a story doesn't need a continuation. Sometimes it just dilutes what's left.