This Unbelievable Coincidence Is Responsible For Life In The Universe

Illustration for article titled This Unbelievable Coincidence Is Responsible For Life In The Universe

Life is dependent upon a lot of coincidences, but there’s only one that was so improbable that physicists laughed at the very idea of it. Here’s why something known as the “beryllium bottleneck” should have choked out all life before it even got started.

When a star ignites, it does so due to the fusion of hydrogen atoms in its core. Hydrogen atoms fuse together to make helium atoms. When they do, those atoms fuse together into a specific kind of helium atom, one which has two protons and two neutrons. The inside of a star that has burned through a lot of its hydrogen is swimming with helium-4 atoms. It is at this point that the universe should have stopped.

At least that was the prevailing understanding of nuclear physics going into the 1950s. Further progress should have been impossible, due to a phenomenon known as the “beryllium bottleneck.” There are two possible ways for atoms to progress from helium-4 and hydrogen-1, the two isotopes inside of stars. Hydrogen and helium could combine to make to make lithium-5, with three protons and two neutrons. This isotope is unstable, and is unlikely to be made in a core mostly made of helium. The only other possibility was two helium-4 atoms fusing to make beryllium-8.

Illustration for article titled This Unbelievable Coincidence Is Responsible For Life In The Universe

Beryllium-8, with four neutrons and four protons, has a half-life of around 10−17 seconds. The universe should have ended with stars pouring their energy into making an endlessly disintegrating series of beryllium atoms.

Enter Fred Hoyle, who made a reasonable assumption. If he was able to sit at a desk and wonder why beryllium didn’t stamp out all life in the universe, beryllium couldn’t possibly have stamped out all life in the universe. The question was, how did anything build from that fragile molecule? His answer came when he realized that three helium-4 atoms coming together would make carbon-12, the most abundant isotope of carbon in the universe.

But Hoyle’s answer came with another problem. Even if two helium atoms came together to form beryllium, and another helium atom came along before the beryllium disintegrated, the impact should simply blow the whole structure apart. Energy has to be gained and shed in distinct quantities, and there was no energy level of carbon-12 that would work. Hoyle worked out what the energy level would be, and proposed that someone find it.


Many thought it was ludicrous, but Hoyle was persistent and bold, and finally got the attention of experimental physicists William Fowler and Ward Whaling. Six months later, and what do you know? It was confirmed that an isotope that lasted for only a fraction of a second could get hit by a helium nucleus, and result in a previously-undiscovered energy state of carbon-12, which could be dissipated by a gamma ray, which is why I’m sitting here typing this and you’re sitting there reading it.

[Sources: Fusion: The Energy of the Universe, by Gary McCracken and Peter Stott; Beryllium, by Rick Adair; In Search of the Multiverse, by John Gribbin]


Image: ESO/B. Tafreshi, Second Image: NASA/JPL-Caltech

Share This Story

Get our `newsletter`


Or maybe the beryllium-8 took over the Universe and we’re all just computer simulations they run for amusement; to see what might have happened if their plans for Universal domination had never come to fruition.

You got to admit with names like Hoyle and Ward Whaling, sounds like something a beryllium-8 grad student would come up with to be ‘funny’.