Image: Netflix

There’s been no shortage of fan-made tributes to Stranger Things (remember the cute Peanuts homage, Merry Christmas Will Byers?) But this latest one comes direct from Netflix, and it’s a faux-trailer for Love in the Upside Down—about a girl named Nancy and the two very different dudes vying for her heart.

Stranger Things season two—which will presumably revisit this burning teenage love triangle in some capacity—hits Netflix October 27.