Valorie Curry in Blair Witch. Image: Chris Helcermanas-Benge

We were already looking forward to the new movie from Adam Wingard (The Guest, You’re Next) when it was called The Woods, and we had no idea it would be a sequel to The Blair Witch Project. Now we can barely contain ourselves waiting for its release, especially since each new trailer looks scarier than the last.

This newest trailer proves that the only thing more terrifying than the Blair Witch is being trapped underground in a claustrophobic, muddy tunnel... with the Blair Witch lurking behind you in the dark. “I don’t want to go in there,” the character protests—with good reason, it appears. Did her friends forget about the witch’s fondness for underground spaces?

Click here to view this embed.

Blair Witch is out September 16.