The Gifted Isn't Trying to Be an X-Men TV Series and That's What Makes It Good

Image: Fox
Image: Fox

One of the more curious things about The Gifted was how little about the show Fox revealed in the months leading up to last night’s premiere. We knew it would feature a family on the run from the mutant-hating government and a handful of classic X-Men characters, but not much else aside from that.

Details about The Gifted were vague and for ages, the only footage of the show that Fox was willing to release were from a handful of scenes that you’d expect from a show about mutants being hunted. Because The Gifted, like Legion, was pitched as a show independent of the X-Men movies or any one specific X-Men story arc from the comics, Fox’s choice to play their cards to the chest was as baffling as it was frustrating.

After having watched the premiere, though, Fox’s decision makes a certain kind of sense. The Gifted is trying to tell one of the most X-Men™ X-Men stories that’s been on broadcast television in decades, but unlike most of its predecessors, the focus isn’t on the larger than life heroes or their cool powers. The Gifted really wants you to care about its characters and see them as people.

Illustration for article titled iThe Gifted/i Isnt Trying to Be an iX-Men/i TV Series and Thats What Makes It Good

While being harassed by a bunch of bullies at a school dance, Andy Strucker’s (Percy Hynes White) nascent mutant powers violently manifest themselves for the first time and almost tear down the building on top of dozens of students. Andy’s older sister Lauren (Natalie Alyn Lind) reveals herself to be a mutant as well and rushes her brother home as footage of the event hits the internet.

The Strucker kids make it to their home and immediately come out to their mother Caitlin (Amy Acker) who qrealizes that her family is in danger just as government agents show up at their front door. The Struckers flee into the night and contact father of the family Reed (Stephen Moyer,) a lawyer who specializes in prosecuting mutants caught using their powers illegally. From there, the family begins to frantically search for a way out of the country in hopes of finding refuge where mutants aren’t as persecuted. The Struckers find unlikely allies in the underground mutant resistance headed up by Polaris (Emma Dumont), Eclipse (Sean Teale), Thunderbird (Blair Redford), and new recruit Blink (Jamie Chung).


If you’ve spent any time at all reading about or watching the X-Men, The Gifted’s premise will sound like familiar, well-trodden ground that gets right at the heart of one of the franchise’s central ideas: mutants are a feared, misunderstood minority.

But rather than establishing that idea and quickly shifting to focus on people using their cool abilities to battle, The Gifted not-so-gently reminds you that it isn’t really a story about superheroes fighting to protect the disenfranchised. It’s first and foremost a story about a family forced to drop everything and start running for their lives.

Illustration for article titled iThe Gifted/i Isnt Trying to Be an iX-Men/i TV Series and Thats What Makes It Good

There’s a hollowness to many of Fox’s X-Men movies that stems from the odd lip-service they speak to the idea of mutant persecution while never quite managing to make that persecution feel real. The students at Xavier’s school are in a near-constant state of danger from the government, sure, but a lot of that has to do with the way that the X-Men repeatedly insinuate themselves into extremely strange situations. The widespread fear and hatred of mutants that would drive a student to Xavier’s always feels conspicuously missing or halfhearted.


The Gifted, by comparison, is chiefly concerned with creating avworld that feels definitionally hostile towards mutants in an all-encompassing way. Though it’s been a slur for mutants in Marvel’s books for decades, the word “mutie” isn’t a big part of Fox’s X-Men franchise, but when their mother says it an offended Andy informs her that the politically correct term is “person of genetic difference.” When Reed’s forced to confront the role that he plays in a legal system that isn’t designed to protect mutants’ civil rights, he ashamedly admits that he knows how some mutants are simply disappeared by the government rather than given fair trials.

The Gifted’s is a world where you honestly wouldn’t want to be a mutant because it would very likely mean living in a constant state of fear that someone or something—like sentinel drones—would expose and lock you away in the name of protecting the public.


The Gifted makes it difficult to forget those stakes because it keeps its level of action and tension relatively down to earth for its cast of characters. The show knows its budget and understands just how to pull off its handful of powers-heavy scenes in a way that conveys the danger everyone’s in. Where Legion’s powers at times felt outsized and improbable, The Gifted’s come off as cool, but not so ridiculously buffed that the mutants are always guaranteed to get away.

The Gifted’s relative down-to-earthiness is definitely one of its stronger suits, but what will be interesting to watch as the season progresses is how the show decides to have its characters move throughout the world. The Strucker family’s on-the-run act worked well as a scene-setter but going forward, it’s going to be important that we see them and the mutant underground doing more than just running.


Eventually, they’re going to have to make a stand and fight their battle in the public eye, the only place it can ever really be one. Let’s hope their journey to that battlefield is an exciting one to watch.

Assorted Musings:

  • Everything about the school dance scene from Andy being attacked in the showers to Lauren fighting through the crowd is plucked right out of Brian de Palma’s Carrie.
  • It seems odd that the Struckers wouldn’t have all undergone testing for the x-gene given Reed’s job. Also, if Lauren’s had her powers for years, it’s surprising that neither of her parents have seen her ever use them. Also, the effect used for Lauren’s powers is basically every shower curtain I’ve ever ha.
  • The X-Men animated series theme song is still a damned good tune.
  • There’s a bit of logical inconsistency when it comes to Blink’s powers. She says that she can’t safely open portals to places that she can’t see, but then opens a portal somewhere she can and the toy she sends through still ends up being cut in half. Maybe she’s still learning?
  • Anybody else catch this excellent wolverine cameo?
Illustration for article titled iThe Gifted/i Isnt Trying to Be an iX-Men/i TV Series and Thats What Makes It Good

io9 Culture Critic and Staff Writer. Cyclops was right.

Share This Story

Get our newsletter


Angrier Geek

I’m going to be honest: the very reason you like it is the reason I turned it off after ten minutes: I need it to be connected to the X-Men to care. I fully admit without that carrot dangled before me, there wasn’t enough to hold my attention, especially when it’s an extended storyline series like this. Legion sucked me in with its style and storytelling, but this is basically a conventional drama with super powers and that’s just not enough.

Though I’ll be checking these recaps to see if there’s any hardcore geekbait coming down.