This Week's Puzzle Puts Your Logical Reasoning to the Test

Illustration for article titled This Weeks Puzzle Puts Your Logical Reasoning to the Test

Don’t answer this puzzle too quickly. Read the question closely, and consider your answer carefully (especially if you’ve seen this kind of puzzle before).

Advertisement

Sunday Puzzle #45: A Devious Selection Task

This week’s puzzle is a twist on a logic problem devised in 1966 by cognitive psychologist Peter Cathcart Wason (we’ll talk more about its origins next week). It was suggested by reader Barb G., who came across it in economist Richard Thaler’s recently published book Misbehaving: The Making of Behavioral Economics. The puzzle appears below:

On the table before you are four cards:

Illustration for article titled This Weeks Puzzle Puts Your Logical Reasoning to the Test
Advertisement

Your task is to turn over as few cards as possible to verify whether the following statement is true: Every card with a vowel on one side has an even number on the other side. You must decide in advance which cards you will examine.

Click here for a hint, especially if you’ve seen this kind of puzzle before.


We’ll be back next week with the solution—and a new puzzle! Got a great brainteaser, original or otherwise, that you’d like to see featured? E-mail me with your recommendations. (Be sure to include “Sunday Puzzle” in the subject line.)

SOLUTION to Sunday Puzzle #44: A Hidden Star

Last week, I asked you to find the regular, five-pointed star hidden in this illustration. For the solution, I refer you to last week’s comment section, where a number of readers highlighted, outlined, and otherwise identified the star in question.

Advertisement
Illustration for article titled This Weeks Puzzle Puts Your Logical Reasoning to the Test
Advertisement

Contact the author at rtgonzalez@io9.com. Art by Tara Jacoby.

Advertisement

Share This Story

Get our newsletter

DISCUSSION

I would flip over 0 cards. The puzzle doesn’t specify which sides. Instead of thinking about it as front side and back side, I instead look at the left and right sides of each card.

From there, I can state that B is the only card with a vowel on one side (left). And since it also has an even number on its other side (right), I can conclude the statement is true.