The latest episode of Legion is a mind trip. Okay, sure, that’s like saying water is wet—Legion is always trippy—but this one actually goes inside the minds of characters other than David, stripping away their layers and abilities to show them at their most basic core. This episode also has what could be one of the greatest flashbacks I’ve ever seen on television.
In “Chapter 11,” David (Dan Stevens) and Syd are on the hunt for the monk of the Mi-Go Order, with Syd taking on the form of Earth’s most-vicious hunter: a cute kitty cat. As she wanders the halls of Division Three’s headquarters—which I’ve coined the Honeycomb Hideout—she comes across an emergency situation. The monk was hiding in plain sight among the other Catalyst victims, and is now on the loose. As the Honeycomb Hideout is placed on lockdown, David heads into the astral plane to ask Farouk for his help locating the monk, since the monk is able to shield himself from David’s mind.
Here we get an excellent scene between David and Lenny, still trapped in Farouk’s mental clutches. She yearns for something—sex, drugs, death—anything to break free of this stylish hell she’s stuck inside. Lenny tries and fails to die multiple times as David chats with Farouk about the monk. Farouk doesn’t care. Then again, neither does David. Pretty telling, if you ask me.
It’s really hard to feel sympathy for someone like the Shadow King, who preyed on David for his entire life and now has taken refuge inside Oliver’s head. But here, Farouk makes a pretty damn good case for why he’s not the villain David thinks he is—first comparing David’s father Charles “Professor X” Xavier to a colonizer, “a white man” who removed him from his throne without caring about the ramifications, and then presenting himself as a refugee who only hops from body to body in order to survive. The Shadow King might be an irredeemable monster, but he does not like being called a villain. I may not agree with Farouk, and I still think he’ll say anything to get what he wants, but he’s not bad at making his point.
As David leaves the astral plane, no closer to a solution to his monk problem than he was going in, Farouk lays a truth bomb on him: He’s not responsible for spreading the Catalyst that renders people paralyzed (other than their chattering teeth), the monk is. After finding Cary, the only other adult survivor in the whole Honeycomb Hideout, David goes out in search of Syd, whose future self is projecting a message of “HURRY” to prevent her present self from being trapped inside her own mind. You see, the Catalyst creates a maze inside the brain, where victims retreat into a place dominated by their core needs and desires. Ptonomy, the first victim David finds, yearns to be in a world where he can forget (reminder: his ability is photographic memory).
Then, we enter Melanie Bird’s maze, presented as a text adventure game where Melanie is in complete control. It’s a fantastic sequence that turns words into works of art—and I can’t resist loving any show where characters shout command suggestions at each other like “climb down the ladder” or “no, look around first.” We also see the return of that weird monster-on-wheels thing from Melanie’s vapor vision, which is referred to in-game as a Minotaur. David tries and fails to force Melanie out of her mind maze, but the only way out is to play. Her game, her rules. So he sits at the computer and tells her a story, one that reflects where she’s been and what she’s always wanted. I transcribed it because I can’t do it justice:
once upon a time
there was a girl with no dreams
she lived in the right now
then she met a boy
and his dream became hers
except what he didn’t realize
was she already had a dream
and that dream was to
be care free
David doesn’t have long to celebrate this victory of empathy before he’s apprehended by the monk and forced to journey into his mind, to learn the tragedy that befell his order. This whole flashback only takes up a few minutes of the episode, but it’s incredibly evocative. It not only succeeds in introducing us to the Mi-Go Order and their connection to Farouk, but it also create feelings of tension, anxiety, and dread that I’m unable to shake.
Earlier in the episode, we’d gotten a biref glimpse at how Farouk was defeated, leading to his body being taken to the monastery of the Mi-Go Order. Unfortunately, Farouk’s body cannot be killed—so it doesn’t take long before the pounding begins. A slow, methodical thump that not only resonates throughout the entire monastery, but also appears to invade their minds. Slowly, the monks begin to go mad, some going so far as to hang themselves to escape the constant and consistent noise. Those that remain fall victim to the Catalyst. In the same vein as the cheerleader “tic” story narrated by Jon Hamm, their minds create a physical reaction that begins to spread. The only one unaffected is our monk—who, in the final moments of the flashbacks—chooses to leave his brothers behind.
The lone survivor of a tragedy his order did not sign up for, the monk takes control of the admiral to demand the “weapon” that can defeat Farouk. The admiral’s collective insists the weapon does not exist, but Melanie believes that it’s David. However, the monk knows the truth: David is helping the Shadow King. Before he can spill the beans, David transports the two of them to the roof of the Honeycomb Hideout so he can demand the location of Farouk’s body. But the monk can’t share that. He knows that would mean the end of everything, and that all his brothers had sacrificed would have been in vain. He’d rather die, which he does by jumping off the roof, in a heartbreaking end to an even more heartbreaking story. These monks lost everything to fulfill a promise—and in their final moments none of their actions mattered, as the key to fixing everything had already betrayed them.
The episode ends with David traveling inside Syd’s mind in order to save her, with the next episode looking to spend a lot of time exploring Syd’s life and story—which is overdue, in my opinion. It’s still hard to say who’s in the right here, as even David begins to doubt whether future Syd is everything she claims to be. But it’s clear he’ll do anything for love, even if it kills everyone else.
Meanwhile, the ceaseless thumping of Farouk trying to escape his coffin is still resonating in my head, even now.
- The latest “tutorial” narrated by Jon Hamm is based on a true story. The cheerleaders shown coming down with uncontrollable shoulder tics harkens back to the mystery of 18 cheerleaders in Le Roy, New York, who all came down with vocal and physical tics in 2011. The cause of their affliction is still unknown.
- I loved how they used the chalkboard drawings from last season inside Farouk’s sunglasses to symbolize the fight between him and Charles Xavier going on inside his mind. It was a clever call-back and helped viewers understand what was happening during that very quiet scene.
- The phantom limb makes another cameo.
- Before Ptonomy and everyone else fell victim to the Catalyst, Ptonomy’s mind seemed to be invaded by that creepy black goo chicken thing, and Cary noticed the goo inside his mind maze. I’m guessing something else is happening to Ptonomy that’s going to have bigger ramifications later.
- Cary and Kerry’s relationship got some good exploration in this episode, as Cary taught her how to eat, use the bathroom, and other things she’s never had to do before. Her falling victim to the Catalyst and him disappearing makes me wonder how “real” Cary has been following their ordeal—which could explain why he survived the Catalyst. I’m guessing David’s going to play a major role in fixing their unity/division issues.
- Best line of the episode: “Keep your eyes out for a cow.”