The title of John Scalzi's secret project has finally been revealed — it's the intriguing Redshirts, a novel whose one-line synopsis says it all: "What happens when all the expendable ensigns on the exploring starship start comparing notes?" Knowing Scalzi, this book will be poignant as laugh-out-loud funny... but how do you create a cover that lives up to that title?

Above are three rejected cover designs for Redshirts — I love all of them, but as Tor Books' art director Irene Gallo blogs:

They are funny and I like them a lot but we did worry that it may cross the line between "laughing with" and "laughing at."

Advertisement

Instead, cover designer Peter Lutjen decided to go back to his original impulse: a straight-up picture of a red shirt. Here's the final cover:

What do you think? Would a fancier cover have grabbed your eye better, or is it better just to go literal with the red shirt? More details at the link. [Tor.com]

Advertisement