17th Century Seascape Contains a Secret Portrait of a Beached Whale

Illustration for article titled 17th Century Seascape Contains a Secret Portrait of a Beached Whale

For over 300 years, this scene set by Dutch painter Hendrick van Anthonissen appeared to be nothing more than a depiction of a day at the beach. But just a few layers of paint deeper, it had a secret: A giant portrait of a beached whale.


Top image: Scheveningen Sands (post restoration) by Hendrick van Anthonissen, on display at the Fitzwilliam Museum / University of Cambridge

Shan Kuang, a grad student at the Hamilton Kerr Institute, was removing a layer of varnish from the painting as part of a routine cleaning when she was surprised to see what looked like the silhouette of a giant fin rising out from the middle of the sea.


As conservators continued to strip away layers and layers of paint, the figure was revealed to be much, much larger, stretching out of the sea and into the sand. It was, unmistakably, a beached whale. So what is the whale doing there and why was it hidden in the first place?

Intriguingly, Anthonissen left every other aspect of the painting — including the crowd of on-lookers surrounding the whale — exactly as is. Only the whale itself was disappeared, a decision that may have been the result of a compromise between the artist's vision and 17th century social mores. "Over the centuries," says Kuang, "the attitude towards painting has changed. In the past it would be very common to cut a painting or to paint over it to fit aesthetic purposes."

Share This Story

Get our newsletter


Seems a bit presumptuous to me. Were I an artist, I would want folks to exhibit my work as I presented it, not to roll it back to an earlier "draft" form and present it as a more authentic version of my work.

Sure, it's possible the artist bowed to social mores. It's also possible the artist looked at the painting with the whale and thought, "You know, that whale doesn't look very good. I'll just paint over that with some more sea and beach."