Three Things To Keep In Mind About The Big Jack The Ripper 'Reveal'

Illustration for article titled Three Things To Keep In Mind About The Big Jack The Ripper 'Reveal'

According to a WORLD EXCLUSIVE at The Daily Mail, the mystery of Jack the Ripper's identity has been solved by businessman Russell Edwards and forensic expert Jari Louhelainen using DNA evidence. The alleged culprit? A 23-year old Polish barber and longtimer Ripper-suspect Aaron Kosminski.


You can read the lengthy, two-part piece (the first part written by Edwards, the second by Louhelainen) over at The Daily Mail. While there are plenty of criticisms to be made here, the three most important things to keep in mind right now are as follows:

  1. Wouldn't you know it, Edwards has a new book to promote. Naming Jack The Ripper comes out Tuesday, and is the latest in a long line of books that speculate on the identity of the infamous killer.
  2. Edwards and Louhelainen saw fit to announce their discovery to the world – a discovery based on a "DNA breakthrough" that Edwards describes as "innovative," "amazing," and "incredible" – not in the pages of a reputable, peer-reviewed scientific publication, but the Daily Mail.
  3. The discovery hinges on a 126-year-old, unwashed, blood-and-semen-soiled shawl said to have been recovered from the scene of one of Jack the Ripper's murders, though the shawl's actual provenance remains far from certain.

Right. Sure, this is fun and exciting, but take with salt and all that. In the meantime, we look forward to seeing these claims independently verified.



We still have to understand where a hairdresser learned the skills to remove organs as he did. I thought that was always why more learned people and surgeons were implicated. Going to the London Dungeon doesn't make me an expert, but they did have some pretty graphic old photos from the time.

Of course, all of your points are spot on, especially about the new DNA techniques not being in a journal. You don't get anywhere in the scientific community by saving your innovations for the Daily Mail. I am going for my box of Maldon Sea Salt until we see other DNA tests from independent labs.