Last night’s Supergirl was all about making the lovestruck nerd Winn into a sympathetic character, by showing us his psycho supervillain dad. And it worked… until Winn tried to use Supergirl’s sympathy to steal a kiss. And then he gave this weird speech.


Seriously. WTF? The gist of Winn’s speech is, “My dad became a supervillain because he bottled up his feelings about the toy company that stole his designs. And I’m worried I’m going to turn into him. So I can’t afford to keep my romantic feelings for you, my friend and coworker, to myself. In fact, if you don’t go out with me and I become a supervillain who uses crappy toys to blow up small children, that will be YOUR FAULT.”

I think the attempt to make us love Winn was a misfire, somehow.


Meanwhile, Lucy Lane gets a job at CatCo and James Olsen is threatened, but pretends it’s just because he really wants to be a photographer instead of an art director. (Umm… sure.) And Kara pressures the Martian Manhunter into using his superpowers to spy on Max Lord, and it goes badly—because J’onn has no control over his mental powers, but this is somehow Kara’s fault. Also, Max now knows about Supergirl and Alex being sisters. Whoa!

Charlie Jane Anders is the author of All The Birds in the Sky, coming Jan 26 from Tor Books. Follow her on Twitter, and email her.