When a high-maintenance hostess throws an ugly Christmas sweater party, the worst things that can happen are paralyzingly banal small talk and a broken glass of eggnog. That is, until a masked killer with mysterious motivations suddenly starts carving up the guests.

Advertisement

Co-directed by Justin McConnell and Serena Whitney, Do You See What I See? is stuffed with enough tacky Christmas decorations to make your eyes cross, as well as a retro synth soundtrack that melds sinister suspense with holiday tunes. It also culminates in a twist that begs for further exploration—but only if it includes lead actress Caleigh Le Grand, who plays the hostess from hell’s winningly sarcastic sister.