Haven is not a great place to live if you're keen on hanging on to your body parts. Not only is the Bolt-Gun Killer running around collecting bits of their victims, some Troubled person has caused Haven's local upskirt photographer to lose his eyeballs. And, true to form, the Trouble is just getting started.
When Nathan and Audrey are called in on the eyeball theft, their first thought is that the Bolt-Gun Killer has struck again. But the victim, a creeper who has managed to evade any legal (or Gawker-based) repercussions, managed to snap a photo of his attacker: a woman in a white dress. Since Audrey and Nathan seem to think that the Bolt-Gun Killer is a man acting alone at this point, this lady seems to be a different sort of tissue thief.